시안 3개 비교

A daily investment edition that you read, in one calm, highly legible column structure. The first screen is a dated masthead (edition date, snapshot stamp, 'not live') with thick black rules, followed by a front page with one lead story, a left-aligned large Korean serif headline and a short standfirst. A narrow right rail carries a numbered 'what changed' ledger with 5 items (NVDA, QQQ, macro, filings, positions), in the manner of the FT's Most Read list. Below the fold is a dense multi-column section grid separated by thin and thick rules: 싼가 비싼가 (valuation, with different-basis PER values shown side by side and never ranked), 공시가 말하는 것, 돈의 이동 (flows, with missing flow data labelled unknown), 오늘의 포지션 (an honest import empty state). Each story has a kicker, a headline, 2–3 lines and a numbered citation. Clicking a citation or a filing opens the document reader on the right at 1920px, as a split with the article staying visible, and as a full-height sheet at 412px. NVDA and QQQ are 'instrument pages' with a large chart, a period toggle and a compare toggle, and a sticky section index with reading progress. The research answer appears as an 'analysis piece' with footnoted evidence, labelled 'authored snapshot'. At 412px it is a single-column reading rhythm with a bottom search/question bar, a top section tab strip and thumb-reachable controls.

신문 1면이라는 은유가 '무엇이 바뀌었나·싸나 비싸나·공시·자금·포지션'이라는 일일 업무 흐름과 정확히 맞고, 세리프 헤드라인·출처 각주·실제 종가 차트·정직한 빈 상태까지 갖춰 완성도와 개성이 가장 높지만, 스티키 탭이 차트 위에 겹치는 렌더링 결함은 고쳐야 합니다.

Dark instrument workspace with command navigation and docked panels, and no left sidebar. A single top command line (⌘K) is the only navigation: type NVDA, QQQ, 공시 or an authored question and the matching panel docks into the grid. At 1920px the screen is a tiling grid of 3–4 resizable panels with a thin status rail at the top. The rail carries the snapshot stamp 'SNAPSHOT 2026-10-28 04:23Z · NOT LIVE', provider freshness per feed, and unknown counts. The default layout is a macro and flows strip across the top, NVDA and QQQ charts side by side in a rebased compare, a filings feed, and a positions panel. The positions panel is a dashed import target with the honest label '포트폴리오 미연결 — 값 없음'. Clicking any filing or claim opens the document reader as a docked panel with the citation inspector under it, so reading never leaves the workspace. Panels can be pinned, closed and swapped by keyboard (1–4 focus, E expand), and the layout is saved locally. At 412px it becomes a phone experience rather than a squeezed grid. A bottom command bar sits above a tab strip of the pinned panels, a single panel shows full height, and sources open as full-height sheets. Swiping moves between pinned panels.

관제실형 다크 대시보드는 한눈에 많은 지표를 보여 주고 출처·시점·알 수 없음 표기도 충실하지만, 흔한 터미널 다크 스타일에 가깝고 폰에서는 거의 비어 있어 폰 경험이 사실상 미완성입니다.

Question-native evidence canvas, not a sidebar app. The first screen is a horizontal strip of columns that scrolls sideways, like a Finder column view or a murder-board. Column 1 holds today's open questions, ordered by the five daily jobs: what changed, cheap or expensive, what the filings say, where money moves, what to do with positions. Selecting a question opens column 2, an authored answer snapshot with numbered citation markers. Each answer ends in 2–3 'next questions' that branch into column 3 and beyond. NVDA, QQQ and the filing reader are not pages. They open as columns, either from a ticker mentioned in an answer or from the always-on question bar at the top. A ticker column holds a large chart with an NVDA vs QQQ rebased toggle, and a filing column holds the reader. The citation inspector is a hard-edged panel docked on the right at 1920px, so you read answer, chart and source side by side across 4–5 columns. Trail breadcrumbs along the top show the branch path, and a branch can be saved as a local note. At 412px the same model becomes a vertical stack of full-height cards that you swipe between. A bottom question bar sits in thumb reach, sources open as a full-height sheet, and a mini trail shows depth. The portfolio is a column whose honest empty state is a file-drop import area and nothing else.

질문 중심 구조는 아이디어가 좋지만 데스크톱에서 인용 인스펙터 패널이 종목 컬럼을 덮어 값이 잘리고 레이아웃이 겹치며, 밋밋한 회색 카드 위주라 시각적 개성과 완성도가 가장 떨어집니다.